Athletic Hall of Fame
The Carmel Catholic High School Athletic Hall of Fame was established in 1990, and serves to recognize those individuals whose time at Carmel was highlighted by extraordinary success as an interscholastic student-athlete, or as a supporter of the Corsairs and the greater mission of the Carmel Catholic Athletic Department.
Candidates for the Athletic Hall of Fame must be nominated as a member of one of the following umbrella categories, with qualification criteria for each described below.
- Athlete
- Coach
- Partner
Above all else, a qualified nominee for the Carmel Catholic Athletic Hall of Fame must have demonstrated, and should continue to demonstrate, an established commitment to upholding the mission and values of the school community, both while representing the Corsairs, and in the period of time following their tenure in the athletic department.
Athlete Criteria
To be considered for induction into the Athletic Hall of Fame as a student-athlete, a candidate must have graduated from Carmel Catholic High School and must be a minimum of 10 years removed from commencement. For example, a graduate of the Class of 2015 will be eligible for enshrinement in the Hall of Fame Class of 2025.
A qualified student-athlete must have demonstrated exemplary athletic ability and achievement during their time as at Carmel Catholic High School. In addition, a student-athlete's placement in the Athletic Hall of Fame may reflect a record of distinguished athletic accomplishment at the post-secondary and/or professional levels of sport.
Coach Criteria
To be considered for induction into the Carmel Catholic High School Athletic Hall of Fame as a coach, a candidate must have demonstrated extraordinary success while serving as a leader of an individual or team sport during their time as a Corsair. Consideration will be given to qualified Head and Assistant coaches who are nominated for enshrinement.
There is no minimum tenure or period of departure required of coaching candidates. However, to be qualified for selection to the Athletic Hall of Fame, an individual may not be an active coach at Carmel Catholic. In addition, professional accomplishments achieved at other institutions or levels of sport will be granted only limited consideration.
Partner Criteria
To be considered for induction into the Carmel Catholic High School Athletic Hall of Fame as an athletic Partner, a candidate must have demonstrated a remarkable and long-lasting contribution to the success of the Corsairs Athletic Department through their work as a staff member, volunteer, benefactor, or other established position of support.
There is no minimum tenure or period of departure required of athletic partners, and a prospective candidate may be active in their support for the Carmel Catholic athletic community. Nominees must be recognized throughout the Carmel community for their exceptionalism in professional conduct, leadership, loyalty, enthusiasm, or philanthropy.
Hall of Fame Directory
Athletic Hall of Fame: Athletes
| Inductee | Class | Association(s) |
| Sarah Cohen-Smith '13 | 2023 | Gymnastics |
| Jasmine Minor '11 | 2023 | Tennis |
| Michael Morrissey '06 | 2023 | Baseball, Football |
| David Venegoni '08 | 2023 | Football, Baseball, Basketball |
| Andrew Bitto '81 | 2022 | Football, Baseball |
| Sean McGrath '06 | 2022 | Football, Basketball |
| Ryan Williams '08 | 2022 | Football, Wrestling |
| Mary Beth Berg '11 | 2021 | Track & Field |
| Matthew Diedrich '06 | 2021 | Baseball |
| Shannon Howell '10 | 2021 | Track & Field, Golf |
| Kirsten McWilliams '84 | 2021 | Basketball |
| Michael Morici '04 | 2021 | Volleyball |
| Sean Murnane '06 | 2021 | Football, Basketball |
| Taylor Pippen '12 | 2021 | Volleyball |
| Christopher Salvi '08 | 2021 | Football |
| Shane Siefert '10 | 2021 | Wrestling |
| Jeffrey Smith '83 | 2021 | Football, Basketball, Baseball |
| Lauren Feely '13 | 2019 | Gymnastics |
| Hilary Halford '10 | 2019 | Cross Country, Track & Field |
| Megan Paul '12 | 2019 | Track & Field |
| Jake Cochrane '13 | 2018 | Wrestling |
| Kristin Mirski '12 | 2018 | Gymnastics |
| Maddie Ogrinc '09 | 2018 | Soccer |
| John Zeffery '08 | 2018 | Baseball, Soccer |
| Colleen Donovan '06 | 2017 | Cross Country, Track & Field |
| Michael Fitzgibbons '11 | 2017 | Football, Basketball, Volleyball |
| Jim Hanna '98 | 2017 | Football |
| Kelly Schoen '09 | 2017 | Soccer |
| James Looby '04 | 2016 | Football, Track & Field |
| Christine Martinson '02 | 2016 | Basketball, Cross Country, Track & Field |
| Amber Mirski '10 | 2016 | Gymnastics |
| Dan Clinton '07 | 2015 | Football, Wrestling |
| Pat Kimener '04 | 2015 | Football, Track & Field |
| Nikole Viltz '07 | 2015 | Gymnastics |
| Nikki Boland '08 | 2014 | Soccer |
| Edwin Lagunas '08 | 2014 | Soccer |
| Eddie Adamski '05 | 2013 | Football, Track & Field |
| Sara Petermann '08 | 2013 | Soccer |
| Derrick Noble '93 | 2012 | Wrestling |
| Jaran Rutledge '04 | 2012 | Football, Track & Field, Wrestling |
| Kate White '06 | 2012 | Golf |
| Kendall Brown '05 | 2011 | Basketball, Soccer |
| Keli Coleman '05 | 2011 | Baseball, Track & Field |
| Eric Luna '01 | 2011 | Football |
| Jenny Eckhart '05 | 2010 | Basketball |
| Mark Venegoni '04 | 2010 | Basketball, Football |
| Brandon Ziemann '04 | 2010 | Baseball, Football |
| Chris Miller '04 | 2009 | Basketball, Football |
| Curt Salata '93 | 2009 | Baseball, Basketball, Golf |
| Jack Simmons '04 | 2009 | Basketball, Football |
| Kenye Pendleton '94 | 2008 | Football, Track & Field |
| Matt Roe '02 | 2008 | Football |
| Sean Walker '03 | 2008 | Baseball, Football |
| Pat McMahon '01 | 2007 | Baseball, Basketball, Football |
| Christopher Mikrut '89 | 2007 | Basketball, Soccer |
| David Worklan '71 | 2007 | Basketball |
| Matt Ehrhardt '94 | 2006 | Football, Track & Field |
| Jonathan Mikrut '01 | 2006 | Baseball, Football, Soccer |
| Jermaine Williams '93 | 2006 | Baseball, Football |
| Charles Burgoon '94 | 2005 | Football, Track & Field |
| Ruben Rivera '96 | 2005 | Basketball, Football |
| Josh Ward '97 | 2005 | Baseball, Golf |
| Dan Gramm '91 | 2004 | Baseball, Basketball, Football |
| Sarah Smith '91 | 2004 | Basketball, Soccer, Volleyball |
| Todd Staehle '91 | 2004 | Baseball, Football |
| Randy Bierman '89 | 2003 | Basketball, Football |
| Chris Mohr '92 | 2003 | Basketball, Football, Soccer |
| Matt Simmons '90 | 2003 | Baseball, Football |
| Carolyn Curley '91 | 2002 | Basketball, Gymnastics, Soccer, Volleyball |
| Tracie Godwin '88 | 2002 | Basketball, Softball, Volleyball |
| Jim Maciag '91 | 2002 | Football, Track & Field |
| Robert Boreham '81 | 2001 | Baseball, Basketball, Football |
| Shawn Chambers '89 | 2001 | Baseball |
| Susan Wings | 2001 | Softball, Volleyball |
| Tony Bitto '69 | 2000 | Football, Track & Field, Wrestling |
| Christian Iantoni '88 | 2000 | Soccer |
| Jamil Swift '93 | 2000 | Football, Wrestling |
| Sarah Kranz '87 | 1999 | Basketball, Softball, Volleyball |
| Jennifer Logue '94 | 1999 | Gymnastics, Softball, Volleyball |
| Bea Selz '93 | 1999 | Gymnastics |
| Kevin Kristan '79 | 1998 | Baseball, Basketball, Golf |
| Eric Maloney '90 | 1998 | Baseball, Basketball |
| Sarah Mikrut '93 | 1998 | Gymnastics |
| Todd Baczek '90 | 1997 | Football, Track & Field, Wrestling |
| Rob Graham '87 | 1997 | Basketball, Football, Track & Field |
| Jeff Zgonina '88 | 1997 | Basketball, Football, Track & Field |
| Michele Muellner '90 | 1996 | Basketball, Softball, Volleyball |
| Stephanie Seier '90 | 1996 | Basketball, Softball, Volleyball |
| Scott Stahoviak '88 | 1996 | Baseball, Basketball |
| Bryan Muellner '85 | 1995 | Baseball, Soccer |
| Tom Ragen '79 | 1995 | Baseball, Wrestling |
| Rudy Magna '67 | 1994 | Football, Track & Field, Wrestling |
| Joe May '78 | 1994 | Baseball, Football |
| Rod Whittier '86 | 1994 | Basketball, Football |
| Michelle Bruns '88 | 1993 | Basketball, Track & Field, Volleyball |
| Art Bustamante '87 | 1993 | Football, Soccer |
| Joe Pudlo '79 | 1993 | Football |
| Ken Autry '68 | 1992 | Basketball, Football, Track & Field |
| Jim Torres '71 | 1992 | Football, Wrestling |
| Joe Tyler '66 | 1992 | Baseball, Basketball, Football, Track & Field |
| Patrick McKillen '74 | 1991 | Wrestling |
| Amy Stanczak '85 | 1991 | Tennis, Volleyball |
| Frank Belmont '71 | 1990 | Basketball |
| Michael Gavigan '67 | 1990 | Baseball, Basketball, Football |
| Bob Svete '74 | 1990 | Basketball |
| Mike Wagner '67 | 1990 | Baseball, Football |
Athletic Hall of Fame: Coaches
| Inductee | Class | Association(s) |
| Mike Fitzgibbons | 2023 | Football, Track, Wrestling |
| John Halloran | 2023 | Soccer |
| Andrew Bitto '81 | 2022 | Football |
| James Nolan | 2022 | Boys Golf, Hockey |
| Josephine Gerardi | 2014 | Girls Volleyball, Girls Track & Field |
| Joseph Scordino | 2013 | Wrestling |
| Christopher Mikrut '89 | 2007 | Boys Soccer, Girls Soccer |
| David Worklan '71 | 2007 | Boys Basketball |
| Tom Ragen '79 | 1995 | Boys Soccer |
| Joe Pudlo '79 | 1993 | Baseball |
| Frank Belmont '71 | 1990 | Boys Baseball, Boys Basketball |
| Angelo Daberio | 1990 | Baseball, Football |
Athletic Hall of Fame: Partners
| Inductee | Class | Association(s) |
| Andrew Bitto '81 | 2022 | Athletic Director |
| Larry Boller '68 | 2022 | Athletic Trainer |
| Karen LaManna | 1995 | Women's Athletic Director |
| Frank Belmont '71 | 1990 | Athletic Director |
| Angelo Daberio | 1990 | Athletic Director |
| Rev. David Murphy O. Carm. | 1990 | Principal |
Hall of Fame Nomination
Nominations for enshrinement into the Carmel Catholic High School Athletic Hall of Fame must be submitted using the electronic form below. Candidates must meet all stated criteria to be eligible for selection, and nomination forms must be submitted prior to July 1 of each calendar year to receive consideration for the associated Hall of Fame class.
Please note that it is incumbent upon the nominator to make an affirmative case for the Hall of Fame candidate and that Carmel Catholic High School retains the sole right of selection. Nominations received after the July 1st deadline may be withheld until the subsequent review period, and unselected candidates remain eligible in perpetuity.
